01
ICE CREAM · Montclair Center, Montclair
Applegate Farm Ice Cream
Ice cream on the same working farm since 1848.
← TBWE
The Ranking · EAT
The best ice cream in New Jersey
Family operations that have been scooping through five presidents. These are the freezers locals keep coming back to.
4 spots in the running, ranked by upvotes from readers. The order shifts every hour.
02
ICE CREAM · Downtown, Jersey City
Torico Ice Cream Parlor
Family-run since '68. Mamey, guava, and avocado flavors locals grew up on.
03
ICE CREAM · Downtown, Jersey City
Milk Sugar Love
House-made ice cream + cookies with seasonal rotations.
04
ICE CREAM · Downtown, Asbury Park
Cookman Creamery
Vegan-friendly scoop shop in a walk-everywhere downtown.